Overview
Our client, a 20-year-old college sophomore on an academic scholarship, was accused of rape by a fellow student following a party near campus. The allegations threatened not only his freedom, but his education, future career, and reputation within his family and community. He was immediately suspended from school pending disciplinary proceedings and charged criminally by the Commonwealth.Charges
- Rape
- Indecent Assault and Battery on a Person Over 14
- Assault and Battery
Defense Strategy
This case demanded a careful, fact-driven defense that treated the complainant with respect while aggressively protecting our client’s rights. In these cases, public perception and prosecutorial pressure can be overwhelming — which is why we focused on evidence and due process.
- Digital Evidence: We subpoenaed text messages, social media posts, and video footage from the night of the party. These materials showed ongoing consensual communication between the parties before and after the alleged incident, undermining the prosecution’s theory of non-consent.
- Witness Testimony: Multiple eyewitnesses confirmed that both individuals left the party together willingly and appeared affectionate throughout the evening.
- Expert Consultation: We engaged a forensic psychologist to assess the complainant’s statements and timeline for consistency with trauma-based memory patterns. Their analysis highlighted significant discrepancies in the account provided to police.
- Title IX Representation: Simultaneously, we represented our client during the university’s Title IX disciplinary proceedings. Our strategy ensured he was not further prejudiced by parallel investigations.
Outcome
After extensive pre-trial motions and evidentiary hearings, the District Attorney’s Office dismissed all criminal charges due to lack of evidence and credibility concerns regarding the complaint. Separately, the college fully reinstated our client, allowing him to return to class, complete his degree, and resume his life.Result:
- ✅Rape — Dismissed
- ✅Indecent Assault and Battery — Dismissed
- ✅University Suspension — Lifted
- ✅Client’s Record — Sealed and Cleared
Reflections
False accusations can devastate a young person’s life in an instant. At Maloney Law, we understand that being accused does not mean being guilty. We provide aggressive, discreet, and compassionate representation — especially when the stakes include your name, your future, and your freedom.